brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Garibaldi wrote:I been working late today, so I didn't get to see the joke myself, but whilst we sort out how it's going to work best, let's say for now
1. Clean mildly crude = fine
2. Crude, mildly offensive = warning in subject
3. Highly offensive - Overly racist/homophobic/etc = better not.
We're discussing a way of maybe having more offensive stuff in there but I want to check with the guys what they think.
The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
I did that because the thread had posts in it that indicated some members may not have found it acceptable. We're working on the rules for that forum at the minute so best just to abide by the guidelines Gari set out above for now.
The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
I did that because the thread had posts in it that indicated some members may not have found it acceptable. We're working on the rules for that forum at the minute so best just to abide by the guidelines Gari set out above for now.
Only Big Dave was offended. There were several others who posted in the thread who enjoyed the joke. Could you not have just put a '*may offend*' tag on it?
IOV wrote:So will you personally post the joke again if it has been decided its ok?
Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
I did that because the thread had posts in it that indicated some members may not have found it acceptable. We're working on the rules for that forum at the minute so best just to abide by the guidelines Gari set out above for now.
Only Big Dave was offended. There were several others who posted in the thread who enjoyed the joke. Could you not have just put a '*may offend*' tag on it?
No. It was an openly racist joke so until it's been decided whether that will be allowed in the joke forum it was best to remove it for the time being.
The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
I did that because the thread had posts in it that indicated some members may not have found it acceptable. We're working on the rules for that forum at the minute so best just to abide by the guidelines Gari set out above for now.
Only Big Dave was offended. There were several others who posted in the thread who enjoyed the joke. Could you not have just put a '*may offend*' tag on it?
No. It was an openly racist joke so until it's been decided whether that will be allowed in the joke forum it was best to remove it for the time being.
I'd like to know what Garibaldi's viewpoint is on this, as one mod says yes and the other says no.
I do have one question however, and that is: would you have found the joke offensive if a black person had posted it?
Big Dave wrote:The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
I did that because the thread had posts in it that indicated some members may not have found it acceptable. We're working on the rules for that forum at the minute so best just to abide by the guidelines Gari set out above for now.
Only Big Dave was offended. There were several others who posted in the thread who enjoyed the joke. Could you not have just put a '*may offend*' tag on it?
No. It was an openly racist joke so until it's been decided whether that will be allowed in the joke forum it was best to remove it for the time being.
I'd like to know what Garibaldi's viewpoint is on this, as one mod says yes and the other says no.
I do have one question however, and that is: would you have found the joke offensive if a black person had posted it?
Does it matter?
The Stig wrote:Big Dave wrote:The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:Sweatsock wrote:The Stig wrote:brother of destruction wrote:Pretty sure it's fine. Just so long as anything that could be dodgy for work/school/college is flagged in the subject header think it would be fine.
Then why was my Batman joke deleted?
I did that because the thread had posts in it that indicated some members may not have found it acceptable. We're working on the rules for that forum at the minute so best just to abide by the guidelines Gari set out above for now.
Only Big Dave was offended. There were several others who posted in the thread who enjoyed the joke. Could you not have just put a '*may offend*' tag on it?
No. It was an openly racist joke so until it's been decided whether that will be allowed in the joke forum it was best to remove it for the time being.
I'd like to know what Garibaldi's viewpoint is on this, as one mod says yes and the other says no.
I do have one question however, and that is: would you have found the joke offensive if a black person had posted it?
Does it matter?
Yes.
Mr Torrie Wilson wrote:I think it's pretty sad that there's even a debate as to whether racist jokes should be allowed or not.
MTW wrote:We can use other offensive jokes from the 1970s, why can't we slag off the blacks? Huh? HUH??
What is a racist joke?
Garibaldi wrote:One thing we have discussed is having the main section being a "safe for work" joke section - basically the safe stuff, stretching to mildly OTT - and creating a subfolder for the NSFW material. That folder would be like the Private Lounge - only visible to members of a specific group, and to join the group you simply PM the Mod Squad confirming that you accept that the section will include more offensive material and are joining "at your own risk", as it were, thus protecting the forum as you all choose to run the risk. Then the rules would be the same in there as the asylum - excepting aggressively offensive material (such as the N word, venomous gay-bashing, hardcore porn and such like), anything goes.
So now we've reached the point where I throw the question back to the masses for feedback - what's everyone's view on that? Workable?
JK wrote:You know racism aside that joke is actually funnier if the black man is a scouser... and with the number of Liverpool players who've had their houses burgled in the past few years it's not an untrue stereotype
|
|